Unintended consequences: A new threat is rising in China

Recent data has shown China’s factory activity is weak, producer prices have been falling, exports to its key US and South-East Asian markets have slumped heavily – by percentages in the mid-teens – demand for credit is weak and its property market remains depressed.

Loading

Data on China’s retail sales is expected this week and the action of the People’s Bank suggests that, after bouncing back sharply from last year’s lockdowns, they might be faltering amid continuing high levels of COVID infections.

With manufacturing and exports spluttering and the property sector – which once contributed more than 30 per cent to China’s GDP – still distressed, the authorities might feel under pressure to intervene.

The talk of a stimulus package suggests Beijing, which has been reluctant to resort to significant stimulatory measures, is concerned the tepid bounce back from last year’s COVID-impacted economy is faltering and the modest official growth target of “about five per cent” this year is under threat.

That wouldn’t be surprising. The property market has been a major driver of activity in the past but now weighs heavily on China’s growth prospects. Consumers are cautious, youth unemployment in the cities is unpalatably high and China’s traditional reliance on trade to drive growth offers no salvation in a slowing global economy.

Indeed, the contractionary policies employed by the US, European Union and other major advanced economies as they battle 40-year high inflation rates are designed to slow their growth, with spillovers into developing economies and therefore the global economy.

That would inevitably impact a trade-exposed economy, like China’s, even without the distortions to global trade caused by the continuing tariff war on China that Donald Trump started.

Engineering soft landings, whether in the US, China or Australia, may owe as much to good luck as good management.

Joe Biden has continued and then expanded the trade war, with sanctions directed at denying China access to advanced technologies, including the critical input to 21st century products of advanced semiconductors, as well as massive fiscal incentives to redirect investment away from China and towards the US and its allies.

Loading

That’s why the monetary policies deployed in the US and elsewhere can be seen to be contributing to the lack of inflation and the economic slowdown in China. It’s one of a number of unintended consequences of the near-unprecedented monetary tightening that the advanced economies have experienced.

Monetary policies are crude tools that, when deployed aggressively to target inflation rates, will inevitably create collateral damage. In what appears to be the final months of the tightening cycle for economies such as those of the US, Australia and Canada, there are signs of unintended but not unpredictable consequences.

The regional banking crisis in the US, with a spate of bank collapses that spilt over into Europe, was one of them.

Another is the signs of stress emerging in commercial property markets in the US and other economies, including Australia.

Rising interest rates that coincide with inflated input costs are also affecting property developers and builders. Even soundly capitalised and well-managed banks will experience rising losses on loans and mortgages from companies and households now under acute pressure.

In the US, highly leveraged companies have been falling over this year at a rate greater than that experienced in the previous two years combined, amid concerns that contagion from lender and investor risk-aversion and the illiquidity created by tight monetary policies might produce more widespread damage.

The disparity in policy directions between the advanced economies in the West and those of China and developing economies also reflect the broader structural shifts towards deglobalisation, reshoring and friendshoring that have emerged in the post-pandemic environment.

Those trends should have disparate effects on inflation rates.

Loading

They should keep Western inflation rates higher than they might otherwise have been and have a subduing influence over the growth rates that China and trade-dependent developing economies have experienced in recent decades, dampening their inflation rates and threatening deflation in the process.

This is complex and largely uncharted territory for central bankers and other policymakers, with the wildcard of a major war in Europe added to the mix of uncertainties they are confronted with. Engineering soft landings, whether in the US, China or Australia, may owe as much to good luck as good management.

The Business Briefing newsletter delivers major stories, exclusive coverage and expert opinion. Sign up to get it every weekday morning.