Google Proposes U.K. Oversight Role in Retirement of Web Cookies

Google’s retirement of cookies highlights a dilemma in regulating big tech: protecting user privacy and promoting online competition can sometimes be at odds, particularly because one of tech’s most popular business models is targeting advertising at individuals based on their online behavior.

Google, under pressure from privacy regulators and advocates, announced plans in 2020 to get rid of third-party cookies, which many companies use to track individuals’ browsing habits across multiple websites. However, advertising companies have since expressed concerns that Google would benefit from the move, because it has other ways to track users, for instance, by tapping into data from its search engine and Chrome browser.

Google said in a blog post that its proposed commitments include working with U.K. regulators to “resolve concerns and develop agreed parameters” for the new technologies it is developing to replace cookies, which it groups under the moniker Privacy Sandbox.

The company also said it would commit to blocking its own advertising products from accessing users’ web-browsing histories saved in the Chrome browser to target or measure ads. The company had previously promised not to build or use replacements for third-party cookies that track individuals.

The U.K.’s competition authority said it would give competitors until July 8 to comment on Google’s proposed commitments before deciding whether to make them binding. The competition regulator said it would work with the country’s privacy regulator to evaluate Google’s changes on privacy grounds as well as for their impact on competition.

“The emergence of tech giants such as Google has presented competition authorities around the world with new challenges that require a new approach,” said

Andrea Coscelli,

chief executive of the U.K. competition authority.

Google’s move to settle the U.K. probe is its latest effort to cope with a rising tide of competition investigations into its advertising business. On Monday, Google agreed to pay nearly $270 million and to make it easier for competing advertising-tech companies to use its tools, to settle a French antitrust case.

A group of U.S. states led by Texas sued Google in December 2020 for allegedly operating a digital-advertising monopoly. The European Commission, the EU’s top antitrust regulator, has also been investigating Google’s advertising business.

Write to Sam Schechner at [email protected]