Dodgy ‘green credentials’ spruikers force watchdog into action

Ads from the mining, automobiles, petroleum, banking, and superannuation industries, had all been brought to the Ad Standards’ attention.

The AANA’s review comes after a precedent-setting case in October in which the UK’s advertising regulator banned two ads from bank HSBC, saying they were “misleading” consumers when it came to the company’s work to tackle climate change. It was the UK Advertising Standards Authority first action against a bank for greenwashing.

In November, gas giant Shell was forced to remove ads promoting “carbon-neutral” petrol after they were found to be misleading by the Netherlands’ Advertising Code Committee.

Greenwashing, misleading or misrepresenting the extent to which something is environmentally friendly, sustainable or ethical, is on the radar of regulators across the globe. Both the Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (ACCC) and the Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC) say it is their top priority this year and have confirmed there are investigations into greenwashing already underway.

There has only ever been one complaint under the Environmental Claims Code which was upheld by Ad Standards, relating to a digital billboard from the Australian Gas Networks in 2020 with the words, “Greener than anything you’re cooking tonight. Love Cleaner Energy, Love Natural Gas” accompanied by a picture of man in a kitchen holding a tray of lasagne.

The watchdog found that the ad gave an average consumer the overall impression that natural gas is cleaner and greener than any alternate method of cooking that they could use, which was a misleading claim as there are other energy sources which would be considered cleaner and greener than gas. The company removed the billboard from its campaign in response.

Loading

Environmental claims can also be dealt with under the advertising association’s code of ethics, in which businesses can complain about a competitor’s advertising and have the issue determined by an industry jury.

Last year, the Australian ads watchdog upheld a complaint made by sustainable food-service package maker BioPak against its rival, coffee cup wholesaler Pinnacle International Wholesalers, about ads that claimed its disposable coffee cups were plastic-free, fully recyclable and compostable.

The panel took the view that the advertising material had created an overall impression that was misleading or deceptive and which implied a benefit to the environment which was not substantiated. Without any admission, the advertiser agreed to review the material.