Rio Tinto’s big energy transition runs into local issues

Shareholders peppered Thompson with queries about the impact of Rio’s energy transition quest on communities.

Loading

One wanted to know how land obtained for the Jadar lithium mine – that had its permits annulled by the Serbian government in January – would be returned to the original owners. Rio said it was still reviewing its options.

“We desperately need lithium in order to make the transition from internal combustion engines to electric vehicles,” the chairman added.

Roger Featherstone, director of the Arizona Mining Reform Coalition, said the Resolution Copper mine Rio is developing with BHP would be another Juukan Gorge due to its effect on Oak Flat, an area sacred to numerous south-west Native American tribes.

“Your Resolution Copper Mine plan calls for turning Oak Flat into a crater 1000 feet deep and two miles in diameter,” Featherstone said.

“I do not understand how you can announce to the world that you’ll never again destroy a sacred place while at the same time move forward with a project that would do exactly that.”

Resolution Copper’s estimate of the area to be affected by subsidence is about half of Featherstone’s, according to its website, but still covers 40 per cent of Oak Flat.

Thompson pointed out the mine had the potential to deliver 25 per cent of US copper demand.

Even early-stage exploration for copper and nickel in Finland drew criticism due to its proximity to freshwater lakes with endangered species.

For the concerns from Serbia, the United States and Finland, Thompson also promised more community consultation.

The problem for incoming chairman Dominic Barton, who said he wants to strengthen relationships with traditional owners, is what happens when the consultation stops and the answer is still no?

To go ahead with mining risks comparison with the destruction of Juukan Gorge that complied with WA Aboriginal protection laws. To honour local wishes leaves the metals the world needs, and Rio Tinto shareholders want, in the ground.

“There is no doubt we have some work ahead, navigating complex geopolitics, a shifting, competitive landscape, and lots of other societal challenges,” the former Canadian ambassador to China said.

Friday’s AGM was the first for ex-WA treasurer and Aboriginal affairs Minister Ben Wyatt who joined the board in June 2021, three months after leaving government.

Wyatt, who is also a director of gas producer Woodside, said he was excited that Rio Tinto had decided it would be driven by the decarbonisation of the planet.

“Perhaps the great challenge we’ll have in my lifetime,” Wyatt said.

No results of shareholder votes, which included election or reelection of the entire board and an advisory vote on the miner’s climate action plan, were released. Total votes from both meetings will be revealed at the Australian AGM.

The Business Briefing newsletter delivers major stories, exclusive coverage and expert opinion. Sign up to get it every weekday morning.